Trump paper towel-throwing ‘abominable’

Trump paper towel-throwing ‘abominable’

The mayor of Puerto Rico’s capital, San Juan, has described Donald Trump’s visit to the hurricane-hit island as “insulting” and called him a “miscommunicator-in-chief”.

Mayor Carmen Yulin Cruz described his televised meeting with officials as a “PR, 17-minute meeting”.

The sight of him throwing paper towels to people in the crowd was “terrible and abominable”, she added.

Mr Trump tweeted it had been a “great day” in Puerto Rico.

But he also took another swipe at the reporting of his trip.

Tuesday’s five-hour presidential trip to San Juan came two weeks after Hurricane Maria devastated the island, and followed complaints that the US government’s handling of the storm’s aftermath was too slow.

Only 7% of the island has power and more remote parts of the island – a US territory – have been without food, water and basic medical aid.


‘Second-class citizens’

Aleem Maqbool, BBC News, San Juan

It may have been a “great day” in Puerto Rico for Donald Trump, but more than 90% of the 3 and a half million people living on this island remain without power and phone communications.

It means many of them would not have heard his remark about how much the disaster in Puerto Rico was costing the US government.

Nor would they have seen that he only visited Guaynabo, a wealthy part of town, and joked with people there that they no longer needed the torches being handed out.

Many of those we have met who are aware of this week’s visit say this is more evidence that the president views them as second-class American citizens.


Media playback is unsupported on your device

During his televised meeting with emergency responders and officials of Puerto Rico, he went out of his way to praise – and seek compliments for – the federal response.

“Every death is a horror,” the president said, “but if you look at a real catastrophe like Katrina, and you look at the tremendous – hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of people that died, and you look at what happened here, with really a storm that was just totally overpowering, nobody’s ever seen anything like this.”

He then turned to the governor of Puerto Rico, Ricardo Rosello, and asked how many people had died in the storm.

“Seventeen? Sixteen people certified, 16 people versus in the thousands,” Mr Trump said, referring to the 2005 hurricane that killed 1,833 people in New Orleans.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Governor Rosello later clarified that the number of people in Puerto Rico killed by Maria had increased to 34.

Mr Trump also pointed to the impact of the cost of storm recovery on US domestic spending, which was already facing a budget shortfall of $72bn (£54bn), telling Puerto Ricans “you’ve thrown our budget a little out of whack… but that’s fine”.

After his meeting, he toured in and around San Juan, stopping at a church to hand out relief supplies and throwing paper towels into the crowd.

At one point he reportedly glanced at a pile of solar-powered flashlights and – apparently unaware of the ongoing power problems – said “you don’t need ’em anymore”, the Washington Post reports.

Mayor Carmen Yulin Cruz told MSNBC after the visit that his meeting with officials had been a PR exercise in which “there was no exchange with anybody, with none of the mayors”.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

She went on to say: “This terrible and abominable view of him throwing paper towels and throwing provisions at people, it really – it does not embody the spirit of the American nation, you know?”

She said his comments about throwing the US budget out of whack were “insulting to the people of Puerto Rico”, and his comparisons with Katrina “minimised our suffering”.

“Well you know what? They are dying. They don’t have the medical resources,” she pointed out.

Ms Cruz said he had become “sort of like miscommunicator-in-chief” who showed no interest in reaching out to those who were suffering. But she went on to say “his staff, on the other hand, seemed to want to approach this a different way”.

She tweeted after the meeting:

Ms Cruz had been called a poor leader by President Trump in a tweet at the weekend after she accused his administration of “killing us with the inefficiency”.

On Tuesday, she shook hands with him and told him: “It’s about saving lives, it’s not about politics”. He did not respond.

Following the visit, the White House announced it was preparing to send a $29bn (£22bn) disaster aid request to Congress.

Of that, $13bn would be for hurricane victims in Puerto Rico, Florida and Texas, while the other $16bn would be for the government-backed flood insurance programme.

Read more